Economic Hard Landing Abroad Threatens Expansion of Brazil's Ethanol Industry

The issue of whether the Brazilian economy can decouple from the fate of the economies of the U.S. and Europe remains a nagging one, with many economists and academics arguing that other countries would pick up the slack in the event of an OECD-led economic slowdown. However, as any contraction in money markets abroad would directly impact the dozens of joint ventures and greenfield projects currently being developed in Brazil's ethanol and sugar industry by foreign companies, understanding the extent to which the Brazilian economy and those of the more developed countries are connected seems prudent.

The Ministry for Development, Industry and Foreign Trade points to the diversification of Brazil's portfolio of trade partners and to the increase of commerce with China as a counterpoint. But the United States still took in an estimated 15.8% of Brazilian exports in 2007, while China acounted for 6.9%. Further, in the case of dampened demand in the U.S. for Chinese products, the Brazilian commodities sector - which has seen massive capital expenditures over the past few years, including a number of acquisitons abroad by companies like Vale - would probably take a hit. Risky undertakings in Brazilian biofuels would likewise feel intense pressure, as it is not clear whether financing from abroad would be forthcoming.

In fact, Unialco, a well-run sugar and ethanol operation in the interior of Sao Paulo state, attempted to float USD150 million dollars in bonds, but gave up when Standard and Poor's gave the company a B ("Very speculative") rating. While recognizing that the long-term prospects for Brazil's sugar and ethanol industry look good, Standard and Poor's also noted that the cyclical nature of Unialco's business, which generates weak cash flows during the off-season (November-April) and requires substantial increases in working capital during the harvest (May-October), raises the riskiness of the business - a problem, notes S&P, inherent to all commodities.

The need for electricity produced by distilleries from burning bagasse (crushed sugarcane) should also bode well for the medium term - Brazil faces a looming power shortage, the result of a complex set of factors that includes natural gas disruptions from Bolivia, shortages in Argentina, and less-than-expected precipitation that resulted in low levels at the dam reservoirs that account for approximately 70% of all the electricity generated in Brazil. However, it is not clear that all the investments in bagasse-based generation will come on-stream in time to stave off shortages.

A modern refinery today derives around 10% of its income from the sale of excess power to the public grid. As most sugar and ethanol companies are located in the state of Sao Paulo, also home to the bulk of Brazil's industry, disruptions to ethanol projects would affect the delicate balance of (electric) power that keeps both mill owners and industrialists happy. Their support is essential to the stability of the administration of President Lula, who started out his political career as a union leader on the industrial outskirts of the city of Sao Paulo in the late 1970s. A power shortage now would tarnish his economic credentials, which have never shone as brightly.